AI Fakes Holocaust Victims Sparking Outrage
AI Generated Holocaust Images Spark Condemnation
The Auschwitz Memorial has strongly condemned the use of artificial intelligence to create fake images of Holocaust victims, calling it a "profound act of disrespect." This condemnation comes after a popular Facebook page was discovered posting fabricated portraits of individuals murdered by the Nazis.
Facebook Page 90s History Under Fire
The Facebook page, known as '90’s History', has been sharing AI-generated black-and-white images purporting to be Holocaust victims. These images are accompanied by reworded factual information that appears to be copied directly from the Auschwitz Memorial’s official communications.
An investigation by Jewish News reveals striking similarities between the AI-generated portraits and authentic archival photos from the Memorial. For instance, the page posted a polished, stylized AI image of Helena Waterman-de Jong, a Dutch Jewish woman deported to Auschwitz in 1942, replacing the genuine, grainy photograph originally shared by the Memorial.
In another disturbing instance, a post on the page fabricates a birthday scene for Léon Gorfinkel, a French Jewish child murdered in Auschwitz, even including a digitally created cake.
Auschwitz Memorials Scathing Response
The Auschwitz Memorial released a sharply critical public statement on Thursday. They warned that such content misleads viewers and "turns memory into manipulation."
The statement declared, "The use of artificial intelligence to generate fictional images of Auschwitz victims – as done by the Facebook page ‘90’s History’ – is not a tribute. It is a profound act of disrespect to the memory of those who suffered and were murdered in Auschwitz."
They further emphasized, "These are not real photos of the victims. They are digital inventions… that risk turning remembrance into fictionalised performance."
Distortion of Historical Facts
The Memorial accused the page of lifting names, dates, and biographical information from its own posts, substituting authentic historical material with what it termed "aestheticised distortion." One such AI-generated image depicted a fictionalized Auschwitz orchestra: a clean, modern image of men in uniform performing in an immaculate hall, a stark contrast to actual historical photographs from the camp.
Concerns Over Historical Distortion and Education
Karen Pollock, chief executive of the Holocaust Educational Trust, stated that employing generative AI in this manner poses a significant threat to Holocaust education.
"It blurs the line between truth and fiction, undermining public understanding and hindering efforts to combat Holocaust distortion and denial," Pollock explained in a statement to Jewish News.
At the time of this report, the Facebook page was still active. Jewish News has reached out to Meta, Facebook's parent company, for a comment.
Call to Action Respect the Victims
In a direct appeal, the Auschwitz Memorial urged the operators of the '90’s History' page: "Stop using artificial images. Stop contributing to disinformation. Respect the victims."
