Illinois Bill Limits AI Teaching In Colleges

The increasing capabilities of Artificial Intelligence (AI) are raising new questions and challenges across various sectors, including education. A significant concern in recent years has been the potential for college students to misuse tools like ChatGPT for academic dishonesty, such as writing papers or cheating on assignments. While this issue is indeed problematic, a new legislative measure in Illinois is shifting the focus to how educational institutions themselves, specifically professors, utilize AI.

Illinois Bill Proposes Limits on AI in College Instruction

According to a report by Newsweek, a bill recently passed by the Illinois Senate with a 46-12 vote aims to regulate the use of AI in community colleges. The core of this legislation would bar these institutions from using artificial intelligence as a complete replacement for human instructors in teaching classes.

OpenAI To Offer Commercial Version Of ChatGPT Getty Images

While student misuse of AI for cheating is a major concern leading some schools to forbid AI use, this Illinois bill specifically addresses its application by faculty.

AI as a Tool Not a Teacher

The proposed Illinois law acknowledges a role for AI in education but sets clear boundaries. It would permit instructors to use AI to "augment course instruction." However, critically, the AI could not be the "sole source of instruction for students." This distinction emphasizes AI as a supportive tool rather than a primary educator.

Prompted by Real World Incidents

This legislative action follows incidents that have highlighted potential issues with AI in teaching. For example, a situation arose at Northeastern University where a student demanded a tuition refund upon discovering that their professor had used ChatGPT to formulate lecture notes. Such cases underscore student expectations for human-led education.

Differing Political Viewpoints

The bill has sparked debate among Illinois lawmakers. Republicans argue that the legislation places unnecessary restrictions on community college boards. They point out that these restrictions could be particularly challenging for colleges in areas where recruiting human instructors is already difficult.

On the other hand, Illinois Democrats contend that the bill is essential for guaranteeing students receive proper instruction. They also state that it acknowledges the vital roles that teachers, staff, and faculty play in the educational and personal lives of students.

Next Steps for the Legislation

The bill is now set to return to the Illinois House. The House must approve an amendment made by the state Senate before the bill can be sent to Governor Pritzker's desk to be signed into law.

The Ongoing Debate Over AI in Classrooms

The use of AI in educational settings is a topic that currently divides educators. As CBS News reports, some educators support integrating AI into the classroom for supplementary instruction and learning enhancement. Conversely, others argue that it primarily facilitates cheating and could detract from genuine learning experiences.