AI Wonder Or Worry A Global Divide
Global AI Sentiment A Tale of Two Outlooks
People in English-speaking countries including the UK, US, Australia and Canada are more nervous about the rise of artificial intelligence than those in the largest EU economies, where excitement over its spread is higher, new research suggests. A global split over what has been dubbed the wonder and worry of AI appears to correlate with widely divergent levels of trust in governments to regulate the fast-developing technology. The polling of 23000 adults in 30 countries, shared exclusively with the Guardian by Ipsos Mori, also showed a quarter of people globally still do not have a good understanding of what AI is, despite it being widely described as the most transformative technology in decades.
On Wednesday, Abbas Bjorn Ulvaeus revealed he was writing a musical with AI assistance, describing it as like having another songwriter in the room with a huge reference frame.
The Anglosphere Anxiety vs European Calm
Britons appear to be among the worlds most worried people about the rise of AI, with two-thirds of people in Great Britain saying they are nervous about the technology being deployed in products and services, and less than half trusting the UK government to regulate AI responsibly. By contrast half or less than half of people in France, Germany and Italy said products and services using AI made them nervous.
In the Anglosphere US Great Britain Canada and Ireland and Australia there is much more nervousness than excitement, said Matt Carmichael, a senior vice-president at Ipsos Mori. In European markets we see less nervousness, but also just a mid-range of excitement. Some markets are much more positive than nervous, especially in south-east Asia.
Trust in Regulation A Key Differentiator
Only Americans, Japanese people and Hungarians trust their governments less to regulate AI than Britons. The UK government recently delayed a bill intended to regulate AI companies in order to align itself with the stance of Donald Trumps administration in the US. Trust in government regulation is lowest in the US, where the presidents election campaign was bankrolled by Silicon Valley technology oligarchs including Mark Zuckerberg, Elon Musk and Jeff Bezos and he recently proposed a bill preventing new state-led regulations of AI.
By contrast last June, the European Union passed the bloc-wide EU AI Act, which bans AI that poses an unacceptable risk, for example, systems used for social scoring, and requires systems to declare when AI has been used to manipulate or generate content. People in India, where the use of misleading AI-generated deepfake videos marked last years general election campaign, are also among the most nervous about AI being used in products and services.
AI in Media and Content Creation Public Opinion
The polling also revealed widespread opposition to AIs use in creating news articles, films and adverts but an equal acceptance that AI will become the primary producer of these things anyway. The highest levels of excitement about AI were found in Indonesia, Malaysia and Thailand where levels of trust in government regulation were also highest. Polling in those countries was only representative of the more connected urban and educated populations but it showed almost double the levels of excitement as in the whole populations of the US and Great Britain.
AI and the Job Market Fears and Hopes
People in Great Britain were among the most pessimistic about how AI will worsen the job market, with nearly a third fearing AI will replace them entirely at work. Globally, just 31 percent of people think the job market in their country will improve because of AI and 35 percent think it will get worse. But perception of its impact varied widely. Nearly three-quarters of people in Thailand believe it is very or somewhat likely that AI will replace their current job in the next five years, compared with only 14 percent who believe their job will go in Sweden and one in four in the US, Great Britain and Australia.
The Future of AI Content Acceptance or Backlash
Across all 30 countries, the polling showed very few people want AI-created online news articles, films or adverts, but most people think it is likely AI will become the primary producer of all of these things as well as making television programmes, screening job adverts and even creating realistic sports content such as tennis matches between AI-generated players. Carmichael said this could play out either with increasing public acceptance as AI-generated content becomes more widespread or alternatively a backlash.
Some of that resistance is currently being seen with the campaign by musicians in the UK, including Kate Bush and Elton John, for greater protections against copyright infringement by technology companies building large language models LLMs. There have also been lawsuits in the US where novelists from John Grisham to Ta-Nehisi Coates have been pursuing legal action OpenAI and Microsoft for copyright infringement.
