AI Botches Restoration Of Worlds Earliest Photograph
A Glimpse into Photographic Origins
In the early 1800s, the scientific community was buzzing with the potential to capture real world images using light. This quest culminated in 1826 when Joseph Nicéphore Niépce successfully created what is widely recognized as the world's first photograph. This pioneering image, a view from his window at Le Gras, was the result of an exposure process that might have spanned several days.
When Modern AI Meets Ancient Photography
Nearly two centuries later, in an interesting intersection of history and technology, a Reddit user prompted ChatGPT, a sophisticated AI chatbot, to restore and colorize Niépce's historic photograph. The primary challenge with Niépce’s image is its inherent lack of sharpness and detail. Being the very first of its kind, the photographic techniques were far from perfected, resulting in a blurry and ambiguous image.
The AI's Creative Interpretation Versus Reality
While the original photo vaguely shows two buildings and a tree, much of it consists of abstract shapes open to interpretation. A prominent triangular shape in the center of the image is particularly enigmatic; it could represent a road or another building. ChatGPT's algorithm interpreted this ambiguous feature as a building.
Expert Critique Unveils Historical Inaccuracies
The AI's attempt quickly drew criticism, notably from another Redditor who identified as a teacher of photography history. This expert was not impressed with the AI's handiwork.
“Totally inaccurate rendering — and that is not surprising,” the teacher commented. They elaborated on Niépce's method: “His process was called heliography. [He] used bitumen and lavender oil, on a polished pewter plate. The exposure took days, and even then, you can barely see the image.”
Having seen the original photograph multiple times, the teacher offered a crucial correction regarding the AI's interpretation. “So the big triangle shape in the center is not another building or rooftop or any object — it was created by sunlight and shadows over the long exposure, and is the courtyard area. There are two buildings on the right and left, that is clear. A tree in the distance. This was at his estate in La Gras, France. So don’t get so excited about the ‘colorization’ of this iconic image that literally changed the world.”
The Viral Misinterpretation More AI Attempts Emerge
Unfortunately, the initial attempt sparked a trend. More Reddit users began feeding Niépce’s photograph to ChatGPT, requesting similar restorations and colorizations, leading to a variety of imaginative but historically inaccurate depictions.
The Dangers of AI Hallucination in Historical Context
The photography history teacher also noted that their experiences with ChatGPT for information on photography history yielded results that were only “50/50 accurate.” This highlights a broader concern about the reliability of AI in interpreting and presenting historical facts, especially with ambiguous source material.
Preserving Authenticity The Real View from Le Gras
It's worth remembering that Niépce’s associate, Louis Daguerre, later refined this early photographic process, eventually lending his name to the Daguerreotype. For those interested in viewing the authentic piece of history, Niépce’s original photograph, "View from the Window at Le Gras," is preserved and displayed in Austin, Texas, at the Harry Ransom Center.
