Study Reveals AI Is Top Source For Spine Advice
The Rise of Digital Doctors
In today's digital age, more and more people are turning to the internet for answers to their health questions. From a nagging cough to serious back pain, a quick search on a social media platform or a query to an AI chatbot has become a common first step. But how reliable is this advice? A recent study sought to answer this question, specifically for spine-related medical issues, by comparing information from three very different sources: the AI tool ChatGPT, the social media giant TikTok, and the official North American Spine Society (NASS) clinical practice guidelines.
A Head to Head Comparison AI vs Experts vs Social Media
Researchers conducted a cross-sectional study to evaluate the perceived accuracy of spine-related medical advice from these three distinct sources. They gathered recommendations for four common spinal conditions:
- Lumbar stenosis
- Lumbar spondylolisthesis
- Lumbar disc herniation with radiculopathy
- Cervical radiculopathy
This collection of medical advice was then presented to a panel of 16 orthopedic surgeons. These experts were asked to rate the accuracy of each recommendation on a 10-point scale, without knowing which source the advice came from. This method provided an unbiased look at how a medical professional perceives the quality of the information.
The Surprising Verdict Surgeons Rate ChatGPT Highest
The results were striking and consistent across the board: ChatGPT's-generated advice was rated as the most accurate for all four conditions.
Here’s how the average accuracy scores broke down:
- For lumbar stenosis: ChatGPT scored 7.75, compared to 7.00 for NASS guidelines and a low 2.50 for TikTok.
- For lumbar spondylolisthesis: ChatGPT scored 7.56, while NASS received 5.94 and TikTok received 5.31.
- For lumbar disc herniation: The race was closer, but ChatGPT still led with 7.25, just ahead of NASS at 7.06. TikTok trailed with a score of 6.44.
- For cervical radiculopathy: ChatGPT scored a strong 7.13, significantly higher than TikTok at 6.50 and the NASS guidelines, which scored just 4.00.
Across every single pathology tested, the advice generated by the AI chatbot was perceived by medical experts as being the most accurate.
Why Is AI Winning the Information Race
This outcome doesn't necessarily mean an AI is smarter than the collective knowledge of a professional medical society. Instead, the study's conclusions point to a critical factor: accessibility. The NASS clinical practice guidelines are peer-reviewed, evidence-based, and considered a gold standard within the medical community. However, they are typically written for other doctors, using dense, technical language that is almost inaccessible to the average patient.
ChatGPT, on the other hand, excels at taking complex data and translating it into simple, easy-to-understand language. Its ability to provide clear, structured, and conversational responses makes its advice more digestible and, as the study shows, perceived as highly accurate even by experts.
A Call to Action for Medical Professionals
The study's authors emphasize that these findings should serve as a wake-up call for professional societies. While sources like TikTok can be a hotbed for misinformation, the popularity of accessible platforms like ChatGPT presents an opportunity. Medical organizations could adapt their expert-vetted content for dissemination through these widely used digital channels.
By creating patient-friendly versions of their guidelines and potentially leveraging AI tools, these societies can play a more active role in public education, ensure accurate information reaches the people who need it, and help reduce the impact of medical misinformation. This study was highlighted on research platforms that are exploring new ways to disseminate academic work, and you can learn more about these channels and review the academic channels guide to see how this is evolving.
