The Truth Behind The Pope at the Plate Photo

A Heavenly Swing or a Viral Misconception?

In the vast world of the internet, some images are too good not to share. A photo that resurfaced in July 2025, appearing to show Pope John Paul II in full papal robes swinging a baseball bat, is a perfect example. The picture quickly made the rounds, with many users on social media claiming it was an authentic shot of the beloved pontiff, who died in 2005.

While the photograph is indeed real, the man at the plate is not who he seems. The claim has been rated as miscaptioned because the person in the photo is not Pope John Paul II.

Unmasking the Man at the Plate

The man who bore such a striking resemblance to the Pope was Gene Greytak, an American real estate broker who found a second career as a professional papal impersonator. His uncanny likeness to Pope John Paul II brought him a unique form of celebrity.

A quick check using a reverse image search tool traces the image back to its true origins and confirms Greytak as the subject.

The Story Behind the Famous Photograph

The now-famous baseball photo was taken by Rick Silva for The Associated Press in 1996. The setting wasn't the Vatican but the New York Mets' fantasy baseball camp. The moment is detailed in a Los Angeles Times obituary for Greytak, who passed away in 2010. The photo simply captures a baseball fan living out a dream, albeit in rather unusual attire.

A Career Built on a Striking Resemblance

Greytak's resemblance to the pope led to a fascinating career, making appearances at international venues and on screen. His work as an impersonator took him to places like a hotel in Budapest, Hungary, and into American living rooms.

Many might recognize him from an episode of "Golden Girls" titled "The Pope's Ring." His resemblance was so convincing that he became a minor celebrity.

As a devout Catholic, Greytak was careful to ensure his impersonations were never inappropriate. The Los Angeles Archdiocese even told him his performances were respectful and did not violate any canon law, giving him a blessing to continue his unique work.