Tone Deaf AI Advice Sparks Backlash At Microsoft
Microsoft Exec's Bizarre Advice to Laid-Off Staff: Use ChatGPT to Cope
In the wake of devastating mass layoffs within its gaming division, a senior Microsoft executive sparked a firestorm by suggesting that affected employees turn to AI for emotional support and career advice. The recommendation was quickly condemned as tone-deaf, igniting a debate about corporate empathy in the age of artificial intelligence.
An Unconventional Solution to Mass Layoffs
Following a painful wave of layoffs at Microsoft that saw numerous gaming division employees lose their jobs and projects canceled, the atmosphere was understandably grim. In this difficult climate, Matt Turnbull, a senior producer at Xbox Game Studios Publishing, took to LinkedIn with what he framed as his "best advice under the circumstances." His suggestion? Use AI tools like ChatGPT and Microsoft Copilot to cope with the emotional and professional fallout of being laid off.
Your New Career Coach is an AI
Turnbull explained he had been exploring how AI could ease the cognitive burden for those suddenly out of work. He created a collection of prompts designed to help former employees navigate their job search. The suggestions positioned AI as a personal career coach, capable of helping identify new career paths, polishing résumés, and even rewriting LinkedIn profiles. He also provided ready-made text snippets for reaching out to former colleagues and networking for new opportunities.
AI for Emotional Clarity A Step Too Far
The advice took a surreal turn when it ventured into emotional support. In a section titled “Emotional Clarity and Self-Confidence,” Turnbull suggested using these non-sentient AI tools to process feelings of worthlessness. One of his recommended prompts read: “I'm struggling with imposter syndrome after being laid off. Can you help me reframe this experience in a way that reminds me what I'm good at?” This particular piece of advice struck many as deeply inappropriate and out of touch.
A Tone Deaf Response Triggers Backlash
While the idea of using AI for support isn't entirely new, the context made Turnbull's post feel exceptionally tone-deaf. The post, which has since been deleted from LinkedIn, was quickly shared on other social platforms like Bluesky, where the criticism was swift and severe. Comments ranged from a simple “Gross” to a more elaborate, “This is completely detached from reality. I’m sure he meant well, but what the hell was he thinking?”
The Irony of Recommending AI Amid Job Cuts
Turnbull himself noted that “these tools provoke strong emotions in people,” a statement that many felt understated the situation. At a time when AI is widely viewed as a direct threat to jobs and human creativity, having an executive from a company aggressively developing AI suggest it as a balm for layoffs felt like mockery to many. The incident highlights a growing disconnect between tech leadership and the workforce, turning what may have been well-intentioned advice into a symbol of corporate insensitivity.