Shein Features Accused Killer In Product Listing
Shein Pulls Listing Featuring Accused Murderer
Fast-fashion giant Shein has launched an investigation after an image of Luigi Mangione, the man accused of murdering UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson last year, was used to advertise a shirt on its website. The image, which appeared to show Mangione wearing a white, short-sleeved shirt, was featured on a product listing with a price of just under $10.
A spokesperson for Shein confirmed to BBC News that the image was provided by a third-party vendor and was removed immediately upon discovery. "We have stringent standards for all listings on our platform," the spokesperson stated. "We are conducting a thorough investigation, strengthening our monitoring processes, and will take appropriate action against the vendor in line with our policies." It remains unclear how long the image was active on the site or who the third-party seller was.
An AI Generated Likeness
Speculation is rampant online that the image was created using artificial intelligence (AI), though the exact method has not been confirmed. An analysis by BBC Verify using Amazon's Rekognition tool found a 99.9% similarity score between the product image and an authentic court picture of Mangione.
Generative AI expert Henry Ajder pointed out several signs that the image might be AI-generated or manipulated. "This includes the lighting and texturing of the image, particularly of the skin, as well the appearance of a blob-like artifact above the right forearm," Ajder noted. "The right hand also doesn't appear to show typical segmentation of the fingers." He added that creating such an image with AI is significantly faster and easier than using manual photo-editing tools.
The Public Fascination with Luigi Mangione
In April, 26-year-old Luigi Mangione pleaded not guilty to all federal charges related to the fatal shooting of Mr. Thompson, including murder and stalking. Prosecutors are seeking the death penalty if he is convicted.
The case has captured widespread attention on social media, largely fueled by public anger towards America's private health insurance system. Mr. Thompson's killing has led some to celebrate Mangione as a folk hero, with supporters gathering outside the courthouse during his hearings and donating thousands to his legal defense. This public fascination has also led to a wave of merchandise, with Etsy being flooded with clothes featuring his name and Amazon having to pull similar products.
This sentiment is part of a broader cultural phenomenon. According to cultural critic Blakely Thornton, people in the US are often conditioned to trust and empathize with men who have Mangione's appearance.
Not The First Corporate Controversy
This incident with Shein is not the first time Mangione's likeness has caused a corporate headache. In December, the BBC filed a complaint with Apple after its new Apple Intelligence feature generated a false notification summary claiming the BBC had reported Mangione had shot himself. A month later, Apple suspended the feature following this and other errors. Mangione's lawyers have not yet commented on the use of his image on Shein.
