AI Hike Planning Dangers Revealed After Rescue
AI-Assisted Hike Ends in Mountain Rescue
This spring, a hiking trip planned using ChatGPT and Google Maps took a dangerous turn for two individuals on Unnecessary Mountain near Vancouver, Canada. The hikers found themselves stranded by unexpected snow, a situation that ultimately required a rescue operation. This incident starkly highlights the current limitations of artificial intelligence when applied to the unpredictable nature of real-world outdoor navigation.
Ill-prepared for the conditions in just flat-soled sneakers, the pair was caught by surprise by the persistent snowpack common on Vancouver's peaks, even late into spring. Lions Bay Search and Rescue were called in, with team members ascending the mountain equipped with proper boots and ski poles to assist the stranded hikers.
The Rising Trend of Tech-Reliant Rescues
Brent Calkin, chief of Lions Bay Search and Rescue, spoke to the Vancouver Sun about the perils of relying too heavily on unchecked digital advice and information overload. This particular rescue is not an isolated case. Rescue organizations are observing a worrying increase in operations where inexperienced hikers are led into hazardous situations due to misleading information from social media and navigation apps.
In a press release concerning the Unnecessary Mountain rescue, Lions Bay Search and Rescue stated, “This call was a good reminder that AI tools like ChatGPT and Google Maps are not always the best for backcountry navigation.” They strongly urged hikers to consult trusted local sources for planning routes and to always carry essential navigational tools like a map and compass or a dedicated GPS device.
Why AI Fails in Backcountry Navigation
Artificial intelligence models like ChatGPT excel at processing and synthesizing large datasets. However, their use for navigating dynamic backcountry environments is fraught with significant risks. A key issue is that current AI systems cannot deliver real-time updates on critical factors such as sudden weather shifts, unexpected trail closures, or current snow conditions. As the Unnecessary Mountain incident showed, mountain conditions can change rapidly, making previously gathered information outdated and potentially hazardous.
AI's reliability plummets for less-traveled trails or situations demanding specific, nuanced outdoor expertise. In such cases, AI can be dangerously inaccurate or even "hallucinate," inventing non-existent trails or recommending unsafe paths. Furthermore, the quality of AI-generated advice heavily depends on the user's ability to formulate precise and thorough questions. Novice hikers, who might not know what crucial information to ask for, are particularly susceptible to receiving incomplete or dangerously misleading guidance.
Real-World Examples of AI Misguidance
The potential for AI to mislead hikers isn't just theoretical. For instance, with minimal prompting, Google's Gemini AI incorrectly advised that microspikes were unnecessary for an early spring summit attempt of a Colorado 14,000-foot peak. This kind of advice is dangerous, as attempting such a climb in April without proper traction can have severe consequences.
Caption from original article: With very little prompting, I was able to get Gemini to assure me that I didn’t need to bring microspikes on an early spring summit attempt of a Colorado 14er. Please don’t climb a 14er in April without traction, guys!
Prioritizing Safety: Human Expertise Over AI for Hiking
Embarking on any hike, regardless of your experience level, demands respect for nature, thorough preparation, and a depth of understanding that current AI technology simply does not possess. While AI tools like ChatGPT can be a fun source of inspiration for your next adventure, they must not replace the invaluable human expertise and proven traditional navigation methods. These established practices are non-negotiable for ensuring safe travel in the outdoors.
Featured image: Rescuers ascended Unnecessary Mountain on foot to extract the stranded hikers. Photo: Lions Bay Searcch and Rescue.
